Golf on Long Island

Reader Postcard: Town of Oyster Bay GC

Tony D. from Valley Stream chimes in with some first impressions of the Town of Oyster Bay Golf Course in Woodbury:

"After the first hole, the course becomes really narrow and doesn't let you breathe until the back nine.  #2 is a long, tight par-5 where it's easy to lose a ball in the trees.  I did a double-take when walking up the fourth fairway.  The green is about 80 feet in the air and has three tiers in it.  Boy!  Made par thanks to a strong drive and approach.

"I really liked #6, a downhill par-3 with some crazy slope in the green.  Actually most of the greens have tiers, ridges or knobs.  You really need some experience to know where to be and where not to be on the greens. 

"The back nine is open and driveable.  I hit sand wedge on the par-3 12th.  Finished my twilight round in the dark.  Putting over the slopes on #18 is not really easy if you can't see them."

What's the best 18th hole at Bethpage?

There are five closing holes at Bethpage State Park, all with varying styles and topography.  Which one is your favorite?  Leave an answer here at Golf On Long Island and be eligible to win a dozen Callaway golf balls when our "Nassau 18" is announced in April.

The Black Course's 18th is the most photographed of the Final Five.  However, some feel it doesn't meet the standard set by the preceding 17 holes.  Its main competitors stretch out two holes to the right and three to the left -- on the Red and Green courses.  Red plays to a green set in a stadium-effect hollow and hugged all around by bunkers.  (If the USGA had a vote, it's clear which hole it would select as best.)  Green has a decent finisher that climbs uphill and tip-toes around a tremendous, sunken trap.

On the other side of the clubhouse, Blue and Yellow wrap things up in their own ways, but neither course is known for an exciting finish.  Blue is a down-then-up replica of #9; Yellow is a short and slightly curved par-4.  They bring to a discussion on closing holes what "Veronica's Closet" and "The Single Guy" brought to NBC's old "Must See TV" Thursdays. 

Leave your answer in the comments section below or on the Golf On Long Island Facebook page (click the tab on the right side of this page).  Two winners of a dozen Callaways will be selected next week from this month's pool of contributors.

What's your favorite water-hazard hole in Nassau?

Most golfers enjoy facing a challenging water hazard.  The more demanding the shot, the better.  NBC and The Players Championship at Sawgrass bank on the dramatic nature of a potential late-round splash landing every May.

"Water-hazard hole" is kind of ambiguous, but you get the idea.  Tell us your favorite public hole in Nassau with the threat of a dip in or around the fairway or near the green.  Whether you pick your favorite based on strategy or simply for the view, you can't be wrong.  Unless you pick a hole without a water hazard.

Leave your answer in the comments section below or on the Golf On Long Island Facebook page (click the tab on the right side of this page) and you're automatically eligible to win a box of GOLI Callaway Warbirds.  The most common response will be selected for our "Nassau 18," which will be announced next month.

You can also go back and answer last week's "Best Par-3" question if you missed it.

So, what's your favorite water hole in Nassau?  (Click here for a list of courses by county.)

Want to win a dozen GOLI golf balls? Help us select our "Nassau 18"

Want to win a dozen Golf On Long Island golf balls?  Just answer a quick question on your local public golf courses and help us put together our "Nassau 18."

Like most sports fans, we here at Golf On Long Island love a good list.  And to help us get through the final weeks of winter and the first few chilly weeks of spring, we are preparing our "Nassau 18", a collection of the county's best public golf holes, by hole number -- much like Golfing Magazine's annual Dream Golf Club.  

The list will be published on Wednesday, April 6 -- the day before the Masters gets underway.  Until then, Golf On Long Island will ask for your opinion each week on Nassau's best golf holes.  All you have to do is leave an answer and you're automatically eligible to win a dozen Callaway Warbirds emblazoned with the GOLI logo. 

Answer in the comments section below (click on the post title if you don't see the comment field) or visit the GOLI Facebook page by clicking on the link in the right sidebar to leave your answer on the wall.  Two winners will be selected randomly from the pool of participants and contacted by e-mail or through Facebook later this month.  The most common answers will be selected for the Nassau 18.

This week's question:

What is Nassau's best public par-3?  (Click here for a list of courses by county.)

Reader postcard from Merrick Road Park

Loyal Golf On Long Island reader Corey W. from Manhattan dropped by the golf course at Merrick Road Park for a quick nine last weekend while in town for a wedding, and was nice enough to provide his take on the course and its conditions.  Corey, who says he normally plays in the Bronx at Pelham/Split Rock, played Merrick on a Saturday afternoon after some pretty strong rainstorms late last week.  "Despite the rain," he says, "the course was actually in very solid shape."

Pace of play was slow, as expected at that time of day, but the three-hour round won't necessarily keep Corey from dropping by again in the future.  "Merrick is easy to play with a wide-open layout and few real hazards," he writes.  "It allows for a fairly smooth round without trips into weeds searching for wayward shots.  The most interesting aspect of play, making up for the lack of major hazards, is the constant wind."

Corey was irked by the absence of yardage markers at the tee.  "One hole was 40 yards longer than the scorecard listed," he says.  "Fortunately I was playing with someone who had a laser rangefinder." 

Bethpage, Eisenhower, Crab Meadow honored by Long Island Press readers

The Long Island Press wrapped up its fourth annual "Best Of Long Island" poll last month.  Each year the newspaper invites readers to vote on its website for their favorite Long Island restaurants, pizzerias, museums, shops, parks --- pretty much their favorite Long Island anything.  The 2009 poll included more than 175 "Best Of" categories.

In the Public Golf Course category, Press readers voted Bethpage the best on the Island for the second consecutive year.  Eisenhower Park and Crab Meadow make up the rest of the Island's top three -- in reality a top nine when you include all five Bethpage and all three Eisenhower courses.  The Press calls Bethpage Black a "work of art." 

"Five [Bethpage] courses of prime fairways, bunkers and greens," says the Press, "and you could play them all and pay less than some other private clubs charge for one round."

The local praise for Eisenhower Park golf comes a few months after the Red Course received four stars in Golf Digest's 2008-09 Best Places To Play listing.  Crab Meadow's eighth hole, a short par-5 with a lake guarding the green, is part of Newsday's Dream 18.

Smithtown Landing a new GolfonLI fave

I got a call from Rob this afternoon asking for a suggestion on somewhere to play on his off day that didn't require an eastbound journey on the LIE.  I've been hearing and reading good things about Smithtown Landing and recommended that he check it out.

A few hours later Rob buzzed me with a text message...

"Hands down one of my favorite courses on the Island."

Looks like we'll be checking it out before the weather takes a turn toward frigid.

Reader Favorite: Timber Point Blue #5

AD of Valley Stream is a fan of the fifth hole at Timber Point's Blue course, another favored hole that is a member of Newsday's Dream 18.  The par-3, named "Gibraltar," is renowned for its treacherous wind conditions and view of the bay:

It overlooks Great South Bay and has bunkers in front on the left and the right.  Wind is a big factor here and is usually a one- to two-club change depending on the direction.  With water to the left and fescue to the right this hole is my favorite for the level of difficulty as well as the need for accuracy, which varies in my game from day to day.

Reader Favorite: Bethpage Red #1

Matt K. of NYC submits the opening hole at Bethpage Red as a personal favorite.  Matt is not alone -- widely considered one of the region's toughest first holes, #1 at the Red was chosen by Newsday readers for the Long Island Dream 18.  The downhill tee shot, sometimes with a half-dozen foursomes looking on as they wait their turn, kicks off one of the more intimidating holes around.

One of my favorite holes on Long Island has got to be the first at Bethpage Red.  Driving the ball from the elevated tee box into a ravine-like fairway gets the adrenaline flowing for the round.  After walking down the steep slope to your drive, you are then faced with one of the toughest shots the Red has to offer - a long approach shot that feels like it is 45 degrees uphill to the small green.  Get out of there with a bogey, and it feels like a birdie.