[This flyover was updated on June 26, 2023.]
Golf courses are certainly not difficult to find across Long Island. No matter where you're sitting, it's likely that a flagstick is dug into a golf hole somewhere within a 15-minute drive. Par-3 courses, however, are a different story. Sometimes during the ongoing love-hate relationship between golfer and driver, you just want to leave home with only a few irons and a putter, but not with the range as the destination. The par-3 course satisfies competitive instincts while allowing for some much-needed short-game practice and time away from the woods and long irons.
Unfortunately for Nassau golfers, the prevalence of par-3 courses is skewed in Suffolk's favor. Once you pass the Nickerson Dunes course along the Nassau beaches, the closest one is farther east in Babylon. Sumpwams Creek -- short for E. Donald Conroy Golf Course at Sumpwams Creek, a Babylon Village muni -- is one of seven public par-3s on the Island, six of which are found in Suffolk. Its nine holes range from distances of 90 to 180 yards, totaling 1,156 yards from the "back" tees. Most of the holes are short and simple. It is an attractive spot for short-iron and wedge practice, as well as a Masters Wednesday-type par-3 competition between friends, albeit without the azaleas.
LAYOUT:
Sumpwams Creek opens with a 90-yarder, where a lone bunker offers protection from very short pitches to the left side. The 124-yard second hole features gentle mounding on the right side of the green and out-of-bounds within reach of bad pulls on the left.
A pond sits in the back end of the property, with holes #3 through #5 playing around its perimeter. Only one shot on the course finds water infringing upon its line to the flag, that being the tee shot on the 100-yard third. Bunkers guard against shots well short or left of the green, and the pond only threatens balls that are topped or chunked off the tee. The green on the 104-yard fourth slopes gently toward the back in the direction of two bunkers. Hole #5 might be the most uncomfortable hole for beginners -- there's a fence and OB to the right, and the pond splashes over on the left.
The seventh and ninth holes stand out because of their distance and their degree of difficulty in comparison with the rest of the course. Both are a bit more hazardous and require execution of skillful shots.
The 167-yard seventh has a slightly raised green that falls off on all sides. Players who let carelessness creep into their swings after six short, non-threatening holes can easily find themselves in the sand or ricocheting off greenside mounding. The ninth is the course's longest hole, a 180-yarder with a large bunker on the right of the green's front half. A diagonal green forces players to go up and over the bunker if they want to get home on the last tee shot of the day.
CONDITIONS:Sumpwams Creek was built in 1999 on the site of an abandoned lumber yard. For a course that's wedged into a tight corner between Route 231 and the Long Island Railroad, it manages to keep a surprisingly bucolic vibe. The sounds of train whistles, the rumble of railroad tracks and the whoosh of cars at highway speed all melt into the background -- assuming, of course, that a train horn doesn't blast as you stand over a birdie putt. They are all in plain sight, but the course still offers tranquil charm. The pond adds to the atmosphere.
Also enhancing the atmosphere are smooth, attractive greens with refreshingly few ball marks. Surfaces are small to medium-sized and typically flat. A few greens are gently sloped -- the fourth from center to back, the sixth from center to front, and the ninth from right to left.
Yardage can vary by 20-30 yards or more given the lengthy tee boxes. The 100-yard third can play closer to a 60-yard pitch with tees up, for instance.
A small clubhouse with a television and back patio replaced what used to be a check-in trailer in the mid-2010s. There is a small practice green right outside.
HOLE(S) TO REMEMBER:
On a standard 18-hole course, the 180-yard ninth probably wouldn't inspire too many second thoughts. At Sumpwams Creek, however, it's much more unique. Chances are you'll be pulling a long iron from your bag for the first and last time all day, and for most golfers who struggle to smack a 4-iron straight under normal circumstances, this is not a preferred situation. A weak push to the right will either stay short of or find the bunker and set up a blast or pitch where the green slopes away from you. Pulled shots will run into trees left of the green. Kudos to the player that can grab a cold long iron or hybrid and find the green with its only swing of the day.
The third hole may stand out to the beginner and the young player due to the water element. A corner of the pond sticks into the target line, but far enough from the green to only intercept balls that either don't get off the ground or are popped straight into the air.
AREA(S) TO AVOID:
If the goal at Sumpwams Creek is to practice a variety of short-game shots, the bunkers on #7 are a great place to drop a few balls. If the goal is to score or compete in a friendly match, it would be in your best interests to steer clear of these traps. Falling short of the green on this 167-yard hole leaves you with a delicate bunker shot over high grass faces -- probably the diciest shot on this otherwise harmless course.
NEARBY COURSES:
Bergen Point (2 miles)
Peninsula Golf Club (8 miles)
Brentwood Country Club (10 miles)
WHERE TO GRAB A BITE AND A BEER:
The heart of Babylon Village -- with its wide variety of food options -- is just a few turns from the course's front gate. Babylon is the place to be if you're into tacos -- surf-themed Swell Taco and Tex-Mex Del Fuego are a few doors apart, and the latter features a wealth of tequila. Lily's and Argyle Grill & Tavern offer the classic bar-and-grill setting. For coffee and a pastry before nine holes, turn to Jack Jack's Coffee House.
CONTACT:
75 Cedar St., Babylon 11702
(631) 669-2340
Have thoughts and opinions on Sumpwams Creek? Share them with other Golf On Long Island readers by posting in the comments section below.
I've played Sumpwams several times and found it very pleasant. It is one of the few places I know of where I can simultaneously indulge my two passion: golf and watching trains.
Posted by: Ellis Simon | January 06, 2009 at 12:01 AM